What Makes Cheddar A Sharp Cheddar Cheese?

Sharp cheddar cheese
Photo credit: unsplash.com

Cheese is a staple food in the American diet and is enjoyed by people of all ages. Since ancient times, it has been consumed with the discovery of lactose in milk, making it possible to preserve.

Cheese is also widely considered a versatile ingredient because it can be eaten on its own, used as part of other dishes, or as a topping for pasta and salads.

Many people consider sharp cheddar cheese one of their favorite cheeses due to its distinct flavor and versatility.

The word “cheddar” comes from the French word “chèvre,” which means goat cheese. Cheddar cheese is made from cow’s milk, but some mozzarella recipes call for goat’s milk. This leaves the question: what makes cheddar cheese a sharp cheddar cheese?

Defining Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Sharp Cheddar is a type of cheddar cheese that can be made with cow or goat milk. The difference between the two is the amount of whey or water in the milk before it’s curdled.

When you make sharp cheddar with cow’s milk, you end up with more whey than when you make it with goat milk.

Factors that influence the sharpness of cheddar cheese

The factors that influence the sensitivity of cheddar cheese are:

  • The use of animal rennet.

Animal rennet attracts less water to the curds, smoothing the texture and making it easier to produce harder cheeses.  

  • The addition of aged yellow cheese mold.

This mold breaks down proteins in the cheese, making them easier to digest.  

  • Cheddar cheese must be aged for at least 60 days to achieve a sharp flavor.  

Aging at a cool temperature of 50 degrees to 55 degrees Fahrenheit prevents flavor diffusion, adding to the sharpness of cheddar cheese.  

  • The use of the “stone” in the curdling process.

A lot more factors contribute to the sharpness of cheddar cheese, but these four are widely considered to make cheddar cheese a sharp cheddar cheese.

Why does it make your tongue tingle?

One of the most well-known characteristics of sharp cheddar cheese is its distinct and unique taste. When you eat cheddar cheese, you can expect to experience a tingling sensation on your tongue from the cheese’s protein. The proteins are often described as being firm and stretchy.

In addition, some people also report that they experience an acidic feeling on their tongues when they eat sharp cheddar cheeses. This sour flavor is due to lactic acid bacteria used in the manufacturing process, giving the cheese its signature tangy taste.

Another common characteristic of sharp cheddar is that it is somewhat crumbly when eaten, like many other hard kinds of cheese.

This makes it easy to shred or crumble with a fork or knife when eating and allows for more excellent mixing into sauces or other ingredients.

However, some cheeses are more difficult to shred than others because they have less moisture content than other types of cheese.

Different Kinds Of Sharp Cheddar Cheese

While there isn’t a massive difference between cheeses classified as sharp cheddar cheese, there are some fundamental differences.

Aged Cheddars tend to have significantly more sharpness, but not everyone enjoys that level of flavor.

Colby Cheese

colby cheese
Photo credit: Pixabay.com

This type of Cheddar is a variation of traditional yellow American Cheddar, just softer and milder. It’s produced with far less salt than yellow cheddars – between 2% and 3% instead of 11%. 

The finished product tends to taste sweeter – a delicious addition to burgers and other sandwiches! Gouda (Arch Brie) ​ Unlike Yellow Cheddars (often sold with Red Wax), Gouda is an unaged cheddar that can be used for grating or slicing.

It is similar to Bel Paese, an Italian-style cheese that is softer and much less salty than Gouda. It’s creamy and traditionally made in the Netherlands or other Scandinavian countries. It is usually called Holland Gouda abroad because of the origin from which it is produced!

How long should you age the cheese to get a sharper flavor?

The first step in making cheddar cheese is to curdle the milk with rennet, a natural coagulant. The curdling process separates the solids from the liquids and forms a thickened mass of curds.

The cheesemaking process takes place at about 40 degrees Celsius for about four hours until it reaches a pH of 4.6.

This is when the cheese moves into its final phase, which creates the flavor profile that makes cheddar cheese a sharp cheddar cheese.

To get a sharper flavor, you need to make sure that you age your cheddar cheese for at least 90 days or up to three years.

Remember that if you don’t want your cheddar cheese to be quite as sharp, aging it for less time will still produce a flavorful result.

What’s the best way to store the cheese?

The best way to store cheddar cheese is in the refrigerator. It should be refrigerated as soon as opened and consumed within a few days. The cheese will also taste sharper when eaten fresh from the fridge.


What’s the difference between sharp cheddar cheese and regular cheddar cheese?

There is no difference in taste between sharp and regular cheddar cheeses. The difference lies in the milk used to make them, which gives the cheese a more robust flavor.


The sharper the cheddar, the more flavor it has. A sharp cheddar can have a slightly tangy taste and a creamy texture with a browned crust.

Cheddar is a very versatile cheese that can be used in grilled cheese sandwiches, grilled quesadillas, macaroni and cheese, and more. Because of its versatility, cheddar is not only a great example of sharp cheddar but is also used as a base for other cheeses.

So if you are looking for sharper-flavored cheddar cheese, consider this your ultimate guide to finding the right cheese for your next meal!

Rate this post
You May Also Like